The growing use of artificial intelligence (AI) in recruitment has transformed how employers identify and assess potential candidates. From screening hundreds of CVs in seconds to generating automated interview notes, AI promises faster and more efficient hiring processes. 

However, these benefits come with significant legal responsibilities. According to B P Collins’ employment practice, employers must balance innovation with fairness, transparency and compliance with data protection laws. 

Should employers inform candidates when AI is being used during recruitment?

The use of AI during recruitment should be disclosed under GDPR, which protects individuals from automated decision making (or ADM) as this will have a significant effect on their application, right down to whether they get through to the next stage or not. Job applicants have a right to object to ADM and to require a human to view their application.

Is there a risk that AI notetakers or CV-screening tools could introduce bias?

Business people or doctor talking to customer and using laptop at office room.

If the AI’s training data is biased, then the AI will also be biased. For that reason, a human review of the output is essential to check that the scores make sense. If using an AI to score CVs, be critical of the scores. Don’t treat them as being infallible. If a CV has been marked down but you can’t see why, you may want to consider interviewing that candidate anyway.

AI bias is such a risk because job applicants are protected from discrimination. If your CV-screening tool is biased against one particular protected group, you could face discrimination claims in the employment tribunal and defending such claims is costly and complex. This is particularly the case if you need help from the company running the AI tool to help defend against the claims, because you may not have a detailed understanding of the algorithm yourself.

What are the best practices for using AI responsibly when hiring?

Keep the humans in HR. Not only is it a legal requirement under GDPR for AI decisions about recruitment to have human oversight, but the people working for your business know it better than an algorithm does. AI is a tool to help your human employees do their work more quickly and more efficiently, but human oversight is the key to minimising legal risk.

AI can enhance recruitment by improving efficiency and reducing administrative burdens, but it must be used responsibly. Employers should always disclose when AI tools are in use, remain vigilant about bias and maintain strong human oversight. By combining technological innovation with legal obligations, organisations can ensure fairer, more transparent and more trustworthy hiring processes.

For further advice and information about best practice in recruitment and AI in HR please contact B P Collins’ employment team or its HR consultancy, HR2Help at enquiries@bpcollins.co.uk or call
01753 889995.

www.bpcollins.co.uk